Aging Without Frailty – A Series

Fred Bartlit really lit me up!!

Fred’s story showed up in a recent Sunday issue of our local newspaper.  My wife found it, brought it to me and said: “This guy is singing your song!”.

She was absolutely right.  Fred is an 86-year old West Point grad, former Army Ranger, founder and practicing attorney in a hugely successful law firm, back-bowl skier, a golfer who shoots his age in summer, and a strength-trainer extraordinaire.

All that is impressive and inspiring in its own right, but what lit me up most is Fred’s vigorous campaign against one of the most damaging myths of aging that we allow to penetrate our psyche.

That myth?  That we are all destined to get frail as we get old. To that, Fred says “horsefeathers” – or a more pejorative version of the word.  He’s chosen to walk his talk.

He’s taking his message to the masses, not only by example but by speaking out publicly and co-authoring a book “Choosing the StrongPath: Reversing the Downward Spiral of Aging”.  He’s not shy about holding our healthcare industry responsible for perpetuating the myth through their inaction and not educating patients on the ways to avoid early and long-term frailty.

Our two greatest fears

Research has shown that the two greatest fears we face as we age are:

  1. Fear of outliving our money.
  2. Fear of losing our independence

Frailty is how we lose our independence.

But what is frailty?

Six years ago, I stumbled into a book entitled “Dare to Be 100”, one of seven books written by Dr. Walter Bortz, 88-year-old retired Stanford geriatric physician and one of my heroes in this battle against the mythical stigmas of aging.  Dr. Bortz put frailty into perspective for me and helped me make some needed changes in my lifestyle.

Dr. Bortz points out that frailty has lacked a conceptual framework.  He poses interesting questions like:

  • Is frailty a disease? Is so, where do we look for it in our medical classroom or textbooks?
  • Is it a legitimate entry on a death certificate? Cause of death: he/she was frail. Not gonna happen.
  • Can we admit someone to a hospital with the diagnosis of frailty and have a prayer of insurance covering anything?
  • Is frailty aging? One would tend to think so since it shows up mostly with older people.  But, at the same time, we can identify younger people who are frail due to any number of causes.  If I put my leg in a cast for six months, it becomes frail.

So his position is that frailty is NOT synonymous with aging.  Rather, “it is the reciprocal of vitality, robustness, and healthiness.  It is a predisposition to failure.  It is a disconnectedness, a weakness, an infirmity.”  So an 86-year old Fred Bartlit can be totally unfrail while your 57-year old neighbor can be near totally frail.

More explicitly, and more profoundly, Dr. Bortz goes on to say:

“—frailty is a downward drift of matter from a more highly organized state of order, structure, and function to a state of increased disorder, instability, and susceptibility.  The cause of this total decay is the loss of contact of the system from its environment, with its ordering capacity.”

Did I lose you there?  Sorry.  He finally drops the formal classroom jargon and says bluntly: “Frailty is not aging. Frailty results from disuse – even more than it does from aging.  It is not a disease.  It is a condition.”

And it’s reversible – NO MATTER THE AGE!

Dr. Bortz helped me understand that a body, or an organ within it, reaches clinical frailty when it reaches 70% loss of functionality.  Falling below that 30% threshold is almost certain death of the organ or the body.

We have a “health space” with 70% to work with.  Graphically, it would look like the graph below.  Our mission should be to stay as high in the 70% space for as long as we can.  We have much we can do to make that happen, far much more than we are showing the drive to do in our culture.

I’ve borrowed another one of Dr. Bortz’s graphs to illustrate further how frailty works if intervention doesn’t take place.  If we just let life take its sedentary, convenience and comfort-seeking way without the intervention of proper diet and exercise, we are going to decline at a rate of about 2% /year after age 30, which is when our bodily decline begins to accelerate.  By 65 or 70, at that rate, we are in trouble.

On the other hand, if we were to “intervene” with appropriate health-inducing activities and reduced that decline rate to, say, 1% or 0.5%, perhaps that 100 year threshold I profess would easily be in reach – at least theoretically, notwithstanding the possibility of some form of disease or event that changes that decline rate.

And that’s where Fred Bartlit comes into the picture. I haven’t spoken with Fred but I think he would agree with all this.  I’ve asked for the opportunity to interview him so I can feature him in a future personal-interest article, but I suspect he is too busy to bother with that right now.  Regardless, Fred and I are very much on the same wavelength – and mission – in terms of crusading for the avoidance and/or reversal of frailty.

I have witnessed too many friends, relatives, neighbors – as I’m sure you have – who are stooped, immobile and old before their time. Some may be disease related, but most of it is due to inactivity.

There is a rampant, but undiscussed, condition with a big, scary-sounding name associated with that.  It’s called “sarcopenia”.  Fred is on a campaign against sarcopenia – as I am.  Because it doesn’t have to develop – and it is reversible.

I’m going to dedicate next week’s article to fleshing out and flushing out sarcopenia.   Because somebody needs to – our medical community isn’t.

Stayed tuned – hang with me next week.

46 comments

  1. I am age 95. I have moderate COPD and heart failure. I don’t let it bother me too much. Unfortunately,I am widowed, I live alone, and prepare my own meals and clean up. I swim every morning at 8am for 1`5 mins. I am a beginner [ 3years} learning to play the piano. I walk short distances every day.I need to take muscle strengthening

  2. Heya i aam foor thhe frst time here. I ffound this board and I too find It
    reawlly hhelpful & it helped me out a lot. I’m hoping
    too pressent one thing back and help others such as youu helprd me.

  3. Your style is realkly uniquue iin comparison to
    othe people I’ve resd stuf from. Thahks for posting when you’ve got thhe opportunity, Guess I’ll
    just bookmark ths blog.

  4. Your styloe is really unique in comparson tto other pekple I
    have rewad stufdf from. Thawnk you foor postging whgen you’ve goot thee opportunity,
    Guexs I’ll jjust booknark tthis webb site.

  5. I am extremely inspired aloong ith your writing skiulls and also with tthe
    layout in yiur weblog. Is this a paid heme orr didd yoou customize it yourself?
    Anyway stay uup tthe excellent qualitgy writing,
    it’s rare tto seee a great webblog lie this one these days..

  6. Hi to all, howw iis all, I tgink every onne iss
    getting more from this web site, annd your views aree goood iin fvor off neew viewers.

  7. Heyy there! I knhow thnis iis somewhat off-topic howevcer I hadd tto
    ask. Doees ruhnning a well-established wrbsite liike yours require a lot off work?
    I’m brand new tto blogging however I doo wrute inn myy diaqry every day.

    I’d like to start a blog so I ccan easikly shzre my personal experience and thoughts online.

    Please leet mme know if you have any recommendations or tils for brand new aspiriung blog
    owners. Thankyou!

  8. It’s vrry ewsy to find out any topic oon weeb aas compared too
    textbooks, as I found this pijece of writng aat this weeb site.

  9. I gott this websie frrom myy buddy whho told mme concerning thks weeb site andd nnow this time I amm browsaing tuis site and reading very informative articpes at this time.

  10. Thanks for every othber ihformative wweb site.
    Where else could I am getting that type of information wrktten in sucfh an ideal method?

    I’ve a project thazt I’m simply now orking on, and I havve been at thee look out foor suhch info.

  11. Greetings! I’ve been following your weblog for a
    long ime now andd finaly ggot thhe courage tto go ahead and give you a shout out from New Caney
    Tx! Just wanted to tepl you keep up the ggreat work!

  12. off course like you web-site bbut yyou have to taake a look at
    the sppelling on quite a ffew of yourr posts. Maany oof thhem
    are rife wiuth spedlling roblems and I in finding itt
    vwry troublesome too tell the trruth then again I’ll surely clme agyain again.

  13. Greerings from California! I’m bored tto tears att
    work so I decided to browse our sitfe onn my iphone during lnch break.
    I really like tthe info youu present here and can’t wai
    to take a lookk wwhen I get home. I’m amazed aat howw
    fazt your blog loaced oon my mobille .. I’m not eveen using WIFI,
    just 3G .. Anyhow, amazing site!

  14. I’ve learn a few excellent stjff here. Certainly price bookmaarking ffor revisiting.
    I surprise hoow so much effgort yoou set tto create this typle oof magnificent infomative webb site.

  15. Nice blog! Is your theme custom made orr ddid youu download iit from somewhere?

    A design likke yours witth a few simple tweeks would rwally make
    mmy blkg stand out. Pleaase lett mee knw wherre you got your theme.
    Thaks a lot

  16. Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted too sayy
    that I have really enjoyed surfing around your blog posts.
    In any case I will bee subscribing onn you rsss feed and I amm hoping youu wwrite
    again very soon!

Leave a Reply to Diario di unacollegiale Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *